Angry Oven Pizzeria

Reviews

• Colin J.

  star star star star star 11 June 2026

  Been there 4 times now and it's still the best pizza in Horseheads! The pizza was really good, the entire menu has been redone and the prices were dropped down from that other idiot who owned it after Jerlandos.
  
  This is a family restaurant and a wonderful staff who makes the food quick, so if you're starving going there is a must and as usual in Jerlandos tradition, the Sunday games are always on for football thank goodness for that!

• Edward A.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 4 June 2026

  The pizza is just ok. I'm not a big fan. It's ok for a fast lunch! It's basic and way over priced for their products. Hope they shape up. Not much left in Bath.

• Stacy P.

  star star star star star 25 May 2026

  I ordered a chicken spiedi salad. This is one of the best chicken salads I've had in a long time. The chicken is perfectly seasoned and shredded on top of a huge salad. It also comes with a loaf of bread. We also ordered loaded fries which were awesome and a meatball Parmesan sub with tons of cheese on top. Everything was really good.

• Sandra D.

  star star star star star_border 22 May 2026

  We found Angry Oven Pizzeria on a random Monday night because all of our usual favorite places were closed. We're glad they were closed -- because we've discovered a hidden gem. Our large party of 12 rearranged the dining room to accommodate our group and the management team took our work in stride. Our pizzas, wings, salads and sandwiches were all delivered in close succession so no one had to wait for food. I tried the salad (huge), Bunny Balls (yummy, trust me) and the Carnivore Pizza. I'm kind of fussy about my pizza sauce (unsweetened) and crust (thin) -- Angry Oven pizza makers and I are on the same page. Overall a great dining experience. Don't expect ambiance, but expect great food.

• Diane O.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 19 May 2026

  Terrible.  I drove there to order 2 cold subs, it was hot and I didn't feel like cooking,  So I went in, placed my order, paid and told them I was going  to wait in the dining area.  There was no air conditioning in the store with the sun beating in, the temp in the store had to be close to 100 degrees.  After waiting close to 10 minutes, a fellow came in and ordered a pizza.  He got his pizza before I got my subs, even with me going to the counter and asking for them (I was told it would be just another minute).  When finally I got the subs, the cashier actually had the nerve to ask me how I was going to pay.....ummmm, already did that, remember?  The subs themself were acceptable but nothing fantastic, certainly nothing to warrant a 1/2 hour + wait!  Do yourself a favor and go to Subway.